James F. Dobson was born in 1830 in Virginia. He died on 20 Jan 1910 in Pennsylvania.
James married Lucy V. Sherman in 1854 in Virginia. Lucy V. Sherman was born in 1832 in York County, Virginia. She died about 1862 in Pennsylvania.
Caroline L. Dobson was born about 1855 in Virginia. She died on 17 Nov 1938 in Alleghany County, Virginia.
Clara Dobson was born on 26 May 1858 in Virginia. She died on 30 Jan 1949 in Alleghany County, Virginia.
Nicholas D. Dobson was born circa 1858 in Pennsylvania. He died on 16 Dec 1952 in Alleghany County, Virginia.
Barbara A. Dobson was born about 1861 in Pennsylvania. She died in 1897 in Virginia.
DNA testing is the best way to prove paternity.